#228: Is Tubing Mascara a Better Alternative for Sensitive Eyes?
When it comes to mascara, people with dry or sensitive eyes have to be extra cautious about what they put near their delicate eye area. While waterproof mascaras are known to be problematic, tubing mascaras are often marketed as a gentler alternative. But are they really the best choice for sensitive eyes?
As a dry eye specialist, I want to help you find makeup that not only enhances your lashes but also protects your eye health. Let’s take a closer look at the pros and cons of tubing mascara and what might be an even better option for sensitive eyes.
What is Tubing Mascara?
Tubing mascara is a unique formula that wraps each individual lash in flexible "tubes" rather than coating them with traditional wax-based pigment. This creates a smudge-proof, long-lasting effect that resists flaking and running. And, tubing mascara is incredibly easy to remove—just warm water and light pressure can slide the tubes right off, no harsh makeup removers required.
Pros of Tubing Mascara for Sensitive Eyes
✅ Easy Removal: Unlike waterproof mascaras that require oil-based removers and excessive rubbing, tubing mascara can be taken off with just water and gentle pressure. This helps reduce irritation for those with dry or sensitive eyes. Get the makeup remover guide for sensitive eyes here.
✅ No Residue Left Behind: Traditional mascaras can leave behind pigment stains or particles, which might migrate into the eyes and cause irritation. Tubing mascara removes cleanly, leaving no flakes or smudges behind.
✅ Long-Lasting Formula: Because it forms tubes around each lash, tubing mascara is resistant to smudging, making it a great option for those prone to eye watering or those who instill eye drops throughout the day.
Cons of Tubing Mascara for Sensitive Eyes
🚫 Contains Potentially Irritating Ingredients: While tubing mascaras may be easier to remove, some formulas still contain harsh preservatives that can be harmful to the front surface of the eye. For example, butylene glycol, a common ingredient in tubing mascaras, can be toxic to the ocular surface and may contribute to irritation or dryness.
🚫 Water-Resistant but Not Waterproof: While tubing mascara is less prone to smudging, it’s still not fully waterproof. If you have particularly watery eyes, excessive tearing could cause the tubes to break down sooner than expected.
A Better Alternative for Sensitive Eyes
If you have dry or sensitive eyes, my top recommendation is Eyes Are The Story Mascara. This brand is specifically formulated for ocular health, meaning it contains no toxic ingredients that could harm the delicate surface of your eyes. Plus, it comes in small, disposable wands, so you can replace them more often to keep your eye makeup hygienic and free from bacteria buildup.
Final Verdict: Should You Use Tubing Mascara?
Although tubing mascara is better than waterproof mascara in terms of removability and reducing eye rubbing, but it’s not always the safest choice for dry or sensitive eyes due to its chemical ingredients. If you’re looking for the healthiest option, a clean, eye safe formula like Eyes Are The Story is a safer bet.
No matter which mascara formula you choose, always remember to remove your eye makeup before bed. Download the Guide to Makeup Removers for Sensitive Eyes to see all my favorite eye safe brands.
